Sanatan Dharma, often referred to as Hinduism, has a vast and profound collection of sacred texts that form the bedrock of its philosophy, rituals, and practices. These texts are broadly categorized into two main groups: Shruti (that which is heard/revealed) and Smriti (that which is remembered/interpreted).

Here’s a breakdown of the great books of Sanatan Dharma:

I. Shruti (Revealed Texts)

These are considered to be of divine origin, revealed to ancient sages (rishis) through deep meditation. They are considered the most authoritative and fundamental.

• The Vedas: The oldest and most foundational scriptures. There are four Vedas, each further divided into four parts:
  • Rig Veda: The oldest Veda, a collection of hymns, prayers, and mantras praising various deities.
  • Yajur Veda: Focuses on sacrificial formulas and rituals.
  • Sama Veda: Contains hymns primarily meant for chanting during rituals, often set to melodies.
  • Atharva Veda: Includes hymns, spells, charms, and philosophical speculations, addressing daily life, health, and well-being.
  Each Veda is further divided into:
  • Samhitas: Collections of hymns, mantras, and benedictions.
  • Brahmanas: Prose texts that explain rituals, ceremonies, and sacrifices, providing detailed instructions and their significance.
  • Aranyakas: “Forest texts” or “wilderness treatises” that offer mystical interpretations of rituals and serve as a transition between the ritualistic Brahmanas and the philosophical Upanishads.
  • Upanishads: Also known as Vedanta (the “end of the Vedas”). These are philosophical and spiritual treatises that delve into the nature of reality (Brahman), the individual soul (Atman), the relationship between them, karma, samsara (cycle of rebirth), and moksha (liberation). Some of the major Upanishads include Isha, Kena, Katha, Mundaka, Mandukya, Taittiriya, Aitareya, Chandogya, Brihadaranyaka, and Prashna.

II. Smriti (Remembered Texts)

These texts are composed by human authors, drawing inspiration from the Shruti. While highly revered, they are considered supplementary and can evolve over time.

• Itihasas (Epics):
  • Ramayana: Composed by Sage Valmiki, it narrates the life of Lord Rama, embodying ideals of dharma, duty, sacrifice, and devotion.
  • Mahabharata: Composed by Sage Vyasa, it’s the world’s longest epic poem, detailing the Kurukshetra War between the Pandavas and Kauravas. It covers a vast range of topics including dharma, ethics, politics, and philosophy.
    • Bhagavad Gita: A pivotal part of the Mahabharata, it’s a dialogue between Lord Krishna and Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra. It offers profound teachings on dharma, yoga (paths to spiritual realization – Karma Yoga, Bhakti Yoga, Jnana Yoga), selfless action, and the nature of the Supreme Being. It is considered one of the most widely read and influential texts in Hinduism.
• Puranas: A vast genre of encyclopedic texts that contain myths, legends, genealogies of gods and sages, cosmogony, cosmology, folk tales, and religious teachings. They are often named after major deities (e.g., Vishnu Purana, Shiva Purana, Bhagavata Purana). The Bhagavata Purana (Srimad Bhagavatam) is particularly significant for Vaishnavites as it focuses on the life and exploits of Lord Krishna.
• Dharma Shastras/Smritis: These are law books and treatises on dharma, moral conduct, social duties, and righteous living. The Manusmriti is one of the most well-known, though its interpretations and relevance in modern times are debated.
• Sutras: Aphoristic texts that condense knowledge into concise statements. Examples include:
  • Brahma Sutras (Vedanta Sutras): Attributed to Vyasa, these systematize the philosophical teachings of the Upanishads.
  • Yoga Sutras of Patanjali: A foundational text for the Yoga school of philosophy, outlining the principles and practices of Yoga.
• Agamas and Tantras: These texts focus on specific deities and offer detailed instructions for temple construction, iconography, rituals, and various spiritual practices, often incorporating esoteric knowledge.
• Darshanas (Philosophical Schools): While not single “books” in the same way as the Vedas or Epics, these represent various schools of Hindu philosophy, each with its own foundational texts. The six orthodox schools (Shad Darshanas) are:
  • Nyaya (logic)
  • Vaisheshika (atomism)
  • Samkhya (cosmology and dualism)
  • Yoga (meditation and spiritual practices, based on Samkhya)
  • Purva Mimamsa (interpretation of Vedic rituals)
  • Uttara Mimamsa (Vedanta, encompassing the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras, and Bhagavad Gita)

This list represents the core and most influential texts of Sanatan Dharma, offering a rich tapestry of spiritual wisdom, philosophical insights, and cultural heritage.

What is Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

Sanatan Dharma, often referred to as Hinduism, boasts a vast and profound collection of “Great Books” that form the foundation of its philosophy, practices, and way of life. These texts are broadly categorized into two main groups based on their perceived origin:

I. Shruti (That which is Heard/Revealed) These are considered divinely revealed truths, heard by ancient sages (rishis) in deep meditative states. They are the most authoritative and fundamental:

• The Vedas: The oldest and most revered scriptures. There are four principal Vedas, each further divided into sections:
  • Rig Veda: The primary Veda, a collection of hymns, prayers, and mantras praising various deities and natural forces.
  • Yajur Veda: Focuses on sacrificial formulas, rituals, and their procedures.
  • Sama Veda: Consists of hymns and melodies primarily meant for chanting during rituals.
  • Atharva Veda: Contains hymns, spells, charms, and philosophical insights related to daily life, healing, and protection.
  Within each Veda, you’ll find:
  • Samhitas: The core collection of hymns and mantras.
  • Brahmanas: Prose texts explaining rituals, ceremonies, and sacrifices, and their deeper meanings.
  • Aranyakas: “Forest treatises” that delve into the mystical and symbolic interpretations of rituals, often studied by hermits.
  • Upanishads: Also known as Vedanta (the “end of the Vedas”), these are profound philosophical and spiritual treatises. They explore the nature of Ultimate Reality (Brahman), the individual soul (Atman), the relationship between them, the concepts of karma, reincarnation (samsara), and liberation (moksha). Key Upanishads include the Isha, Kena, Katha, Mundaka, Mandukya, Taittiriya, Chandogya, and Brihadaranyaka.

II. Smriti (That which is Remembered/Interpreted) These texts are human compositions that draw inspiration and elaborate upon the Shruti. While highly respected, they are considered supplementary and may contain regional or historical variations.

• Itihasas (Epics):
  • Ramayana: Attributed to Sage Valmiki, this epic narrates the life and journey of Lord Rama, embodying ideals of righteousness (dharma), duty, devotion, and sacrifice.
  • Mahabharata: Composed by Sage Vyasa, this is the world’s longest epic poem, chronicling the Kurukshetra War between the Pandavas and Kauravas. It’s a vast repository of ethical, political, and philosophical wisdom.
    • Bhagavad Gita: A central part of the Mahabharata, this is a dialogue between Lord Krishna and the warrior Arjuna. It is considered one of the most important and accessible Hindu scriptures, offering profound teachings on dharma, different paths of yoga (Karma Yoga, Bhakti Yoga, Jnana Yoga), and the nature of the divine.
• Puranas: A vast collection of mythological narratives, genealogies of gods, goddesses, sages, and kings, cosmologies, folk tales, and religious teachings. They often explain Vedic concepts through stories. Important Puranas include the Vishnu Purana, Shiva Purana, and especially the Bhagavata Purana (Srimad Bhagavatam), which focuses on the life and pastimes of Lord Krishna.
• Dharma Shastras/Smritis: These are law books and treatises that codify Hindu laws, ethics, social customs, and moral conduct. The Manusmriti is a prominent example, though its interpretations and applicability are subject to contemporary discussion.
• Sutras: Aphoristic texts that condense complex knowledge into concise statements. Examples include:
  • Brahma Sutras (Vedanta Sutras): Attributed to Vyasa, these systematize the philosophical teachings of the Upanishads.
  • Yoga Sutras of Patanjali: The foundational text for the Yoga school of philosophy, outlining the eight limbs of Yoga for mental and spiritual discipline.
• Agamas and Tantras: These texts deal with specific deity worship, temple construction, rituals, and esoteric spiritual practices.
• Darshanas (Philosophical Schools): While not single books, these represent various schools of Hindu philosophy, each with its own foundational texts and commentaries. The six orthodox schools (Shad Darshanas) are Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Samkhya, Yoga, Purva Mimamsa, and Uttara Mimamsa (Vedanta).

These “Great Books” collectively provide the rich and diverse intellectual, spiritual, and cultural heritage of Sanatan Dharma.

Who is required to read Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

Courtesy: Rahul Manandhar

Ideally, the wisdom contained in the Sanatan Dharma Great Books is meant for anyone and everyone who seeks spiritual understanding, ethical guidance, and a deeper connection with the nature of existence.

While traditionally, certain texts like the Vedas were studied under the guidance of a Guru (teacher) after specific rituals (like Upanayana Sanskar, initiation for male members of certain varnas), and direct access might have been limited, the essence of Sanatan Dharma emphasizes universal principles.

Here’s a breakdown of who benefits from reading these texts:

• Hindus: For followers of Sanatan Dharma, these texts are the primary source of their faith, philosophy, rituals, and way of life. Studying them helps in understanding their heritage, performing religious duties (dharma), and pursuing spiritual growth (moksha).
• Spiritual Seekers: Many individuals, regardless of their religious background, are drawn to the profound philosophical and psychological insights offered by texts like the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita. These texts provide universal principles for self-realization, inner peace, and ethical living.
• Academics and Scholars: Indologists, philosophers, historians, and cultural studies experts study these texts to understand ancient Indian civilization, its intellectual traditions, and its influence on global thought.
• Anyone Interested in Wisdom and Ethics: The Itihasas (Ramayana and Mahabharata) are rich with moral dilemmas, character studies, and lessons on duty, relationships, and human values that resonate across cultures and time. The Puranas offer a wealth of mythological narratives that convey spiritual truths in an accessible way.
• Those Seeking Practical Guidance: Texts like the Bhagavad Gita offer practical advice on how to navigate life’s challenges, perform actions without attachment to results, and cultivate inner peace amidst external chaos. The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali provide a systematic approach to mental discipline and meditation.

Important Considerations:

• Translations and Commentaries: Many of these ancient texts are in Sanskrit and can be quite complex. Reliable translations and commentaries by learned scholars and spiritual masters are invaluable for understanding their deeper meanings.
• Guidance from a Teacher: While not strictly required for all texts, especially for widely accessible ones like the Bhagavad Gita, the guidance of a knowledgeable teacher (Guru) can significantly enhance one’s understanding of the more subtle and intricate philosophical concepts, particularly in the Vedas and Upanishads.
• Open Mind and Reflection: Approaching these texts with an open mind, a willingness to reflect on their teachings, and an intent to apply them in one’s life is crucial for deriving true benefit.

In essence, while traditional learning paths existed, the wisdom of Sanatan Dharma’s great books is increasingly accessible to anyone with a genuine interest in exploring profound spiritual and ethical insights.

When is it required to read Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

While there’s no strict “required” time in the sense of a legal or universally mandated age for reading Sanatan Dharma’s great books, traditional Hindu thought outlines stages of life (Ashramas) where specific types of learning and spiritual pursuits are emphasized. This provides a framework for when certain texts might be more relevant or deeply appreciated.

Here’s a breakdown of how the study of these texts often aligns with life stages and individual spiritual journeys:

1. Brahmacharya (Student Life – typically youth/early adulthood):

• Focus: This is traditionally the period of formal education and learning under a Guru.
• Texts: While direct memorization and chanting of the Vedas were historically reserved for specific sections of society, the emphasis for all was on developing a strong moral and ethical foundation. Stories from the Itihasas (Ramayana and Mahabharata) and Puranas would be introduced to teach dharma, values, and cultural narratives in an accessible way. Basic ethical principles derived from Dharma Shastras would also be absorbed.
• Why it’s important: Laying a strong foundation of values and understanding fundamental concepts early in life.

2. Grihastha (Householder Life – adulthood, family, career):

• Focus: Fulfilling social and familial duties, earning a livelihood, and contributing to society.
• Texts: The Bhagavad Gita becomes particularly relevant here. Its teachings on Karma Yoga (selfless action), performing one’s duties without attachment to results, and maintaining inner peace amidst worldly responsibilities are highly practical for a householder. The moral lessons from the Itihasas continue to offer guidance in navigating complex relationships and ethical dilemmas. Some Puranas also provide guidance on rituals and social conduct.
• Why it’s important: Applying spiritual principles in daily life, balancing material and spiritual pursuits.

3. Vanaprastha (Forest Dweller/Retired Life – gradual withdrawal):

• Focus: Gradually detaching from worldly responsibilities, focusing more on spiritual introspection and meditation.
• Texts: This stage often involves deeper study of the Upanishads and Brahma Sutras, which delve into the ultimate nature of reality (Brahman), the self (Atman), and the path to liberation. The Aranyakas also become more pertinent as they offer mystical interpretations of Vedic rituals.
• Why it’s important: Shifting focus from external duties to internal spiritual realization.

4. Sannyasa (Renunciant Life – complete detachment):

• Focus: Complete renunciation of worldly ties, dedicating oneself fully to the pursuit of moksha (liberation).
• Texts: The deepest philosophical texts like the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras, and advanced treatises on Vedanta are the primary focus. The goal is direct experience and realization of the truths contained within them, not merely intellectual understanding.
• Why it’s important: Final push towards ultimate spiritual freedom.

Beyond Traditional Stages:

It’s crucial to understand that these are traditional guidelines and not rigid rules, especially in modern times.

• Accessibility: With widespread availability of translations and commentaries, anyone can begin reading these books at any age.
• Personal Interest: The “best” time to read these books is when an individual develops a genuine interest and readiness to engage with the profound wisdom they offer. This can happen at any point in life, sparked by personal experiences, curiosity, or a quest for meaning.
• Starting Point: For beginners, the Bhagavad Gita is almost universally recommended as an excellent starting point due to its concise nature, practical wisdom, and comprehensive overview of key Hindu philosophical concepts. The Ramayana and Mahabharata are also great for gaining a narrative and ethical understanding.
• Guidance: While self-study is possible, especially with good translations and commentaries, seeking guidance from a knowledgeable teacher (Guru) can be immensely beneficial for deeper understanding and correct interpretation, particularly for the more intricate philosophical texts like the Vedas and Upanishads.

In conclusion, while traditional Hindu thought suggests an alignment of study with life stages, the true “requirement” for reading Sanatan Dharma’s great books stems from an individual’s spiritual inclination and a desire to explore the timeless wisdom they contain. There is no wrong time to begin such a journey.

Where is it required to read Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

Traditionally, the study of Sanatan Dharma’s great books was primarily confined to specific, sacred spaces and under the guidance of qualified teachers. However, in the modern era, access has become much more widespread.

Here’s a breakdown of where the study of these texts has historically taken place and where it happens today:

I. Traditional/Historical Places:

• Gurukuls/Ashrams: These were residential schools or hermitages where students (brahmacharis) lived with their Guru (spiritual teacher) and learned the Vedas, Upanishads, and other scriptures. The emphasis was on oral transmission, disciplined study, and direct experience.
• Temples (Devaalayas): Temples, beyond being places of worship, often served as centers of learning, particularly for Agamas, Puranas, and the performance of rituals outlined in the Vedas and Brahmanas. Priests (pujaris) and scholars would often reside and teach there.
• Scholarly Centers/Universities: Ancient universities like Nalanda and Taxila were renowned for their in-depth study of various branches of knowledge, including Vedic literature, philosophy (Darshanas), and linguistics.
• Hermitages/Forests (Aranyakas): As the name suggests, the Aranyakas were meant to be studied in the solitude of forests, reflecting a deeper, mystical interpretation of the Vedas away from ritualistic practices.
• Homes: For many, especially within families where spiritual traditions were strong, knowledge of Puranas and Itihasas (like the Ramayana and Mahabharata) was passed down through storytelling, recitations, and daily family practices.

II. Modern Places and Avenues:

• Homes (Personal Study): With the widespread availability of translated scriptures and commentaries in various languages (English, Hindi, Marathi, etc.), many individuals now engage in self-study at home. This is often the most common starting point for anyone interested.
• Temples and Ashrams (Contemporary): Many temples and ashrams worldwide continue to offer classes, discourses (pravachans), and study groups on the Bhagavad Gita, Upanishads, Puranas, and other texts. These provide a structured environment and the benefit of a teacher’s guidance.
• Universities and Academic Institutions: Many universities, both in India and globally, offer courses and degrees in Hindu Studies, Sanskrit, Philosophy, and Religion, where these texts are studied academically and critically. Examples include Nalanda University’s MA in Hindu Studies (Sanātana Dharma).
• Online Platforms and Digital Libraries: The digital age has revolutionized access. Websites, apps, YouTube channels, and online libraries now host vast collections of Sanatan Dharma texts, translations, audio recordings, and video lectures, making them accessible to anyone with an internet connection, anywhere in the world. (For instance, you can find many texts on platforms like Veducation or through various spiritual organizations’ websites.)
• Yoga and Meditation Centers: Many yoga and meditation centers, especially those rooted in traditional Indian philosophies, incorporate the study of texts like the Bhagavad Gita and Yoga Sutras as part of their curriculum, linking textual knowledge with practical spiritual disciplines.
• Study Groups and Satsangs: Informal or organized groups often gather to read, discuss, and reflect on these scriptures, fostering a community of learners.

Is it “Required” to Read in a Specific Place?

No, in the contemporary world, it is not “required” to read Sanatan Dharma’s great books in any specific physical location. The emphasis has shifted from geographical location to the sincerity of the seeker’s intent and the quality of their understanding.

While traditional settings offered distinct advantages (immersive environment, direct Guru-disciple lineage), modern avenues provide unparalleled accessibility. The “where” is less important than the “how” (with dedication, reverence, and an open mind) and the “what” (reliable translations and commentaries).

How is required Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

The phrase “How is required Sanatan Dharma Great Books?” can be interpreted in a couple of ways:

1. “How are these books studied or approached?” (Method of study)
2. “How essential or necessary are these books?” (Importance/Significance)

Let’s address both interpretations.

---

1. How are these books studied or approached? (Method of Study)

The “requirement” for how these books are studied has evolved, but traditional methods emphasized several key aspects:

• Shraddha (Faith and Reverence): Approaching the texts with respect, an open mind, and a sincere desire to learn. This isn’t blind faith but a willingness to engage with the wisdom as potentially transformative.
• Shravana (Listening/Hearing): Traditionally, this was the primary method, especially for the Vedas. Texts were recited and heard from a Guru (teacher). Even today, listening to discourses, chanting, or audio renditions of scriptures is highly valued as it allows for deeper absorption and understanding of the nuances of Sanskrit.
• Manana (Reflection/Contemplation): Actively thinking about the teachings, questioning them respectfully, and integrating them into one’s own understanding. This involves internalizing the concepts rather than just memorizing them.
• Nididhyasana (Meditation/Deep Contemplation): Meditating on the core truths presented in the texts to directly realize them. This is the stage of practical application and direct experience. For philosophical texts like the Upanishads and Brahma Sutras, this is crucial for true understanding.
• Swadhyaya (Self-Study/Recitation): Regular personal reading, chanting, and reflection on the texts. This often involves memorizing key verses or hymns.
• Satsang (Association with Truth/Spiritual Community): Discussing the scriptures with like-minded individuals or spiritual teachers. Debates and discussions help clarify doubts and deepen understanding.
• Guru-Shishya Parampara (Teacher-Disciple Tradition): For profound and esoteric texts, especially the Vedas and some Upanishads, the guidance of a qualified Guru is considered invaluable. The Guru not only explains the literal meaning but also conveys the subtle nuances, practical applications, and the spiritual experience embedded within the text.
• Bhashya (Commentaries): Studying the various commentaries written by great Acharyas (like Shankara, Ramanuja, Madhva on the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras, and Bhagavad Gita) is essential for grasping the diverse philosophical interpretations.
• Anusthan (Practice/Application): The ultimate “requirement” is to live the teachings. Sanatan Dharma is not just about intellectual understanding but about transforming one’s character, actions, and outlook based on the wisdom gained. For instance, understanding Karma Yoga from the Bhagavad Gita means striving to perform actions selflessly in daily life.

In modern times, with translations widely available, many begin with self-study, but supplementing it with reliable commentaries, scholarly resources, and if possible, guidance from experienced teachers, significantly enhances the learning process.

---

2. How essential or necessary are these books? (Importance/Significance)

The “Great Books” of Sanatan Dharma are not just historical artifacts; they are considered absolutely essential for understanding the core tenets, practices, and philosophical depth of the tradition.

• Foundation of Dharma: They provide the definitions of dharma (righteous conduct, duty), karma (action and its consequences), moksha (liberation), and samsara (cycle of rebirth) – the fundamental pillars of Sanatan Dharma.
• Source of Spiritual Wisdom: They offer profound insights into the nature of Brahman (Ultimate Reality), Atman (the individual soul), the cosmos, and the various paths to spiritual realization (Yoga, Bhakti, Jnana, Karma).
• Ethical and Moral Guidance: Texts like the Bhagavad Gita, Ramayana, and Mahabharata are rich reservoirs of ethical dilemmas, moral lessons, and examples of ideal conduct (or consequences of unrighteous conduct). They guide individuals on how to live a purposeful and virtuous life.
• Cultural and Historical Record: They serve as vital records of ancient Indian thought, mythology, social structures, scientific understanding (in some cases), and literary traditions.
• Inspiration and Devotion: Many texts, particularly the Puranas and the Bhakti-oriented scriptures, inspire devotion (bhakti) towards various deities, fostering a personal connection with the divine.
• Basis for Philosophical Schools: The Darshanas (philosophical schools) of Hinduism are all rooted in the interpretations and elaborations of these core texts, particularly the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras, and Bhagavad Gita (collectively known as Prasthanatrayi for Vedanta).
• Living Tradition: Unlike dead languages or forgotten philosophies, these texts remain living scriptures, constantly reinterpreted and applied to contemporary challenges, continuing to inspire millions globally.

In essence, these “Great Books” are the lifeblood of Sanatan Dharma. While an individual may practice aspects of the faith without deeply studying every text, a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of Sanatan Dharma is virtually impossible without engaging with at least some of these foundational scriptures. They are not merely optional readings but are considered indispensable for a complete spiritual journey within the tradition.

Case study on Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

Courtesy: The Facts

A “case study on Sanatan Dharma Great Books” isn’t a single, straightforward scenario like a business case study. Instead, it involves exploring the impact, relevance, and challenges associated with these texts in various contexts, from historical influence to contemporary application.

Here’s a framework for a case study, broken down by key “Great Books” categories and their areas of impact:

Case Study Title: The Enduring Resonance of Sanatan Dharma’s Great Books in a Changing World

Introduction: Sanatan Dharma, with its rich tapestry of scriptures, has permeated Indian culture for millennia and continues to influence millions globally. This case study examines how its foundational texts—Shruti (Vedas, Upanishads) and Smriti (Itihasas, Puranas, Dharma Shastras)—have shaped civilization, adapted to modernity, and addressed timeless human concerns.

I. The Bhagavad Gita: A Timeless Manual for Life and Leadership

• Background: The Bhagavad Gita, a concise philosophical dialogue within the sprawling Mahabharata, addresses Arjuna’s existential crisis on the battlefield. Its teachings by Lord Krishna span duty (dharma), selfless action (karma yoga), devotion (bhakti yoga), knowledge (jnana yoga), and the nature of the self.
• Modern Application (e.g., Corporate Leadership):
  • Case Example: Many modern corporate leaders and management gurus cite the Bhagavad Gita’s principles. For instance, the concept of Nishkama Karma (action without attachment to results) is highly relevant in high-pressure business environments. Leaders are encouraged to focus on their duties and efforts, rather than being solely driven by outcomes (which are often beyond their control), fostering resilience and reducing stress.
  • Leadership Qualities: The Gita emphasizes qualities like equanimity (samatvam), detachment, clarity of thought, decision-making based on dharma, and servant leadership. These are increasingly seen as crucial for ethical and effective leadership in today’s complex corporate world.
  • Ethical Framework: It provides a strong ethical framework, encouraging integrity, fairness, and responsibility towards all stakeholders, aligning purpose with profit.
• Challenges/Opportunities: Applying ancient wisdom to a rapidly changing global economy requires careful interpretation and practical implementation. Opportunities lie in integrating these principles into leadership development programs and fostering a more values-driven corporate culture.

II. The Ramayana and Mahabharata: Moral Compass and Cultural Bedrock

• Background: These two epic narratives are not merely stories but foundational texts that have shaped Indian ethics, social values, and artistic expressions.
  • Ramayana: Explores ideals of kingship, family duty, loyalty, sacrifice, and the triumph of good over evil through the story of Rama and Sita.
  • Mahabharata: A complex narrative of war, justice, and human folly, containing intricate moral dilemmas, political intrigue, and profound philosophical discussions.
• Influence on Indian Culture and Society:
  • Ethical Education: Generations of Indians have learned about dharma, sacrifice, justice, and human virtues through these epics. Characters like Rama, Sita, Lakshmana, Hanuman, Yudhishthira, Krishna, and Karna serve as archetypes for moral behavior, devotion, or consequences of actions.
  • Art and Literature: They are an inexhaustible source for drama, dance, music, painting, sculpture, and regional literature across India and Southeast Asia. Folk traditions, storytelling, and festivals often revolve around these narratives.
  • Social Values: The epics reinforce concepts of family bonds, loyalty, duty towards elders and society, and the importance of righteous conduct in various roles (king, wife, brother, friend).
• Challenges/Opportunities: While deeply influential, interpretations of these epics, particularly regarding social norms and gender roles depicted, sometimes face scrutiny in modern contexts. Opportunities lie in re-examining these narratives for timeless ethical principles that transcend specific historical contexts and promote universal human values.

III. The Upanishads: Bridging Ancient Mysticism and Modern Science

• Background: The Upanishads are philosophical treatises that delve into the nature of Brahman (Ultimate Reality) and Atman (the individual soul), emphasizing their unity. They explore consciousness, reality, and the path to liberation through knowledge.
• Interface with Modern Science and Philosophy:
  • Consciousness Studies: Modern neuroscientists and philosophers of mind find striking parallels between Upanishadic insights into states of consciousness (waking, dreaming, deep sleep, Turiya) and contemporary research on the mind. The idea of consciousness as a fundamental aspect of reality, rather than a mere byproduct of the brain, resonates with some quantum theories.
  • Quantum Physics: Concepts like the interconnectedness of all existence, the observer effect, and the non-dual nature of reality found in the Upanishads are often compared to principles in quantum mechanics. Scientists like Erwin Schrödinger and Fritjof Capra noted these similarities.
  • Holistic View: The Upanishads offer a holistic understanding of existence, emphasizing the interconnectedness of the individual, the cosmos, and the divine, which aligns with modern ecological and systems thinking.
• Challenges/Opportunities: The “science-spirituality” dialogue is complex. While inspiring, drawing direct correlations between ancient mystical texts and modern scientific theories requires careful, nuanced academic work to avoid oversimplification or misinterpretation. Opportunities exist in interdisciplinary research that explores the philosophical frameworks and conceptual models offered by the Upanishads in light of contemporary scientific advancements.

Conclusion: The “Great Books” of Sanatan Dharma are not static relics of the past but living documents that continue to offer profound wisdom and practical guidance. Their enduring relevance lies in their ability to address universal human questions about purpose, ethics, relationships, and the nature of reality. While challenges exist in translating ancient contexts to modern sensibilities, their continued study and application offer immense opportunities for personal growth, societal well-being, and a deeper understanding of human consciousness. The case studies above illustrate how these texts remain vital sources for navigating the complexities of the 21st century.

White paper on Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

White Paper: The Enduring Wisdom of Sanatan Dharma’s Great Books – A Foundational Framework for Universal Values and Holistic Living

---

Abstract

Sanatan Dharma, often known as Hinduism, possesses an unparalleled literary heritage in its “Great Books.” This white paper explores the core categories of these foundational texts—Shruti (Vedas, Upanishads) and Smriti (Itihasas, Puranas, Dharma Shastras, Sutras)—and argues for their continued relevance as a source of universal values, ethical frameworks, profound philosophical insights, and practical guidance for holistic living in the 21st century. Despite their ancient origins, these scriptures offer timeless solutions to contemporary challenges, ranging from individual well-being and moral conduct to societal harmony and the pursuit of ultimate truth.

---

1. Introduction: The Concept of Sanatan Dharma and Its Literary Heritage

Sanatan Dharma, meaning the “Eternal Law” or “Ever-Righteous Path,” is one of the world’s oldest living traditions. Unlike Abrahamic religions with a single sacred book, Sanatan Dharma is characterized by a vast, diverse, and evolving body of scriptures. These texts are not merely religious dogmas but comprehensive treatises encompassing philosophy, ethics, cosmology, ritual, law, art, and spirituality. They are broadly classified into:

• Shruti (That which is Heard/Revealed): Considered of divine origin, heard by ancient sages (rishis), and thus supremely authoritative.
• Smriti (That which is Remembered/Interpreted): Composed by human authors, drawing from and elaborating upon the Shruti, and thus considered supplementary but highly revered.

This white paper will outline the key “Great Books” within these categories and highlight their enduring significance.

---

2. Shruti: The Bedrock of Sanatan Dharma

The Shruti literature forms the foundational layer of Sanatan Dharma, revered as direct revelation.

2.1. The Vedas

The oldest and most fundamental scriptures, comprising four principal collections:

• Rig Veda: The primary Veda, a collection of hymns, prayers, and invocations to various deities representing natural and cosmic forces. It lays the groundwork for later philosophical inquiry.
• Yajur Veda: Focuses on sacrificial formulas, rituals, and their precise execution. It details the practical application of Vedic hymns in ceremonies.
• Sama Veda: Consists of hymns from the Rig Veda set to musical melodies, primarily used for chanting during rituals. Emphasizes the power of sound (mantra).
• Atharva Veda: Contains hymns, spells, charms, and philosophical speculations related to daily life, health, well-being, and protection.

Each Veda is further subdivided into:

• Samhitas: The core collection of mantras and hymns.
• Brahmanas: Prose commentaries explaining the rituals, ceremonies, and sacrifices.
• Aranyakas: “Forest treatises” offering mystical interpretations of rituals, serving as a bridge to the Upanishads.
• Upanishads: The culmination of Vedic thought, focusing on philosophical and spiritual insights.

2.2. The Upanishads (Vedanta)

Often called “Vedanta” (the end or essence of the Vedas), the Upanishads are profound philosophical treatises that form the zenith of Shruti literature.

• Core Concepts: They delve into the nature of Brahman (the Ultimate Reality, the Universal Self) and Atman (the individual soul), emphasizing their non-dual unity (“Tat Tvam Asi – Thou art That”). They explore karma, samsara (cycle of rebirth), and the concept of moksha (liberation or spiritual freedom).
• Universal Relevance: The Upanishads provide a framework for understanding consciousness, existence, and the interconnectedness of all things. Their insights resonate with modern physics, psychology, and philosophy, particularly in discussions on consciousness and the nature of reality.
• Key Upanishads: Isha, Kena, Katha, Mundaka, Mandukya, Chandogya, Brihadaranyaka, Taittiriya, Aitareya, Prashna.

---

3. Smriti: Elaboration, Application, and Narrative Wisdom

Smriti literature, though composed by human authors, is highly revered as it elaborates, interprets, and contextualizes the Shruti principles for practical living.

3.1. The Itihasas (Epics)

These grand narratives serve as a rich source of ethical teachings, historical accounts (mythological), and cultural values.

• Ramayana (Composed by Valmiki): Narrates the life of Lord Rama, an incarnation of Vishnu, embodying ideals of dharma, duty, sacrifice, integrity, and devotion. It showcases ideal relationships (king-subject, husband-wife, brother-brother).
• Mahabharata (Composed by Vyasa): The world’s longest epic poem, detailing the Kurukshetra War between the Pandavas and Kauravas. It is a vast repository of ethical dilemmas, political science, philosophy, and human psychology.
  • The Bhagavad Gita: A pivotal section within the Mahabharata, it is a profound dialogue between Lord Krishna and Arjuna on the battlefield. It comprehensively outlines Karma Yoga (selfless action), Bhakti Yoga (devotion), and Jnana Yoga (knowledge) as paths to spiritual realization. Its teachings on duty, detachment, equanimity, and the nature of the Supreme Being offer a timeless manual for navigating life’s challenges, making it one of the most widely read and influential Hindu scriptures globally.

3.2. The Puranas

A vast genre of encyclopedic texts containing myths, legends, genealogies of gods and sages, cosmogony, cosmology, folk tales, and religious teachings.

• Purpose: They make complex Vedic principles accessible to the common person through engaging narratives. They detail the forms and attributes of various deities (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva, Devi), explaining their roles in cosmic cycles.
• Key Puranas: Vishnu Purana, Shiva Purana, Markandeya Purana, and the highly revered Bhagavata Purana (Srimad Bhagavatam), which focuses extensively on the life and exploits of Lord Krishna.
• Cultural Impact: Puranas are instrumental in shaping popular devotion and understanding of Hindu deities and festivals.

3.3. Dharma Shastras (Law Books)

These treatises codify Hindu laws, ethics, social customs, and moral conduct, outlining principles for righteous living in various societal roles.

• Manusmriti: One of the most well-known Dharma Shastras, providing guidelines on personal conduct, family life, civil and criminal law, and duties of different social groups. While historically significant, interpretations of its social dictates are debated in modern contexts.

3.4. Sutras (Aphoristic Texts)

Concise, aphoristic texts that condense complex knowledge into memorable statements.

• Brahma Sutras (Vedanta Sutras by Vyasa): Systematize the philosophical teachings of the Upanishads, forming one of the three foundational texts (Prasthanatrayi) of Vedanta philosophy.
• Yoga Sutras of Patanjali: The foundational text for the Yoga school of philosophy, outlining the eight limbs of Yoga for mental discipline, meditation, and spiritual realization. It remains the core text for classical Yoga practice worldwide.

---

4. Enduring Relevance and Contemporary Application

The “Great Books” of Sanatan Dharma offer not just historical insights but practical wisdom highly relevant today:

• Universal Ethical Frameworks: Concepts like Ahimsa (non-violence), Satya (truthfulness), Dharma (righteous conduct), Karma (action and consequence), and Seva (selfless service) are universally applicable and crucial for fostering a harmonious society.
• Holistic Well-being: Texts like the Bhagavad Gita and Yoga Sutras provide guidance for mental clarity, emotional resilience, stress management, and finding purpose, contributing to individual well-being in a fast-paced world.
• Ecological Consciousness: The Vedic understanding of nature as sacred and interconnected, and the concept of the divine immanent in all creation, fosters an inherent respect for the environment, aligning with modern ecological movements.
• Inclusivity and Pluralism: The Upanishadic principle of “Ekam Sat Vipra Bahudha Vadanti” (Truth is One, Sages call it by many names) underpins Sanatan Dharma’s inherent pluralism, promoting respect for diverse paths to truth and fostering interfaith dialogue.
• Personal Transformation: The emphasis on self-inquiry, self-realization, and transcending ego in texts like the Upanishads and Yoga Sutras offers profound pathways for personal growth and spiritual evolution.

---

5. Challenges and Opportunities

While invaluable, engaging with these texts presents certain challenges:

• Linguistic Barrier: Most original texts are in Sanskrit, requiring reliance on translations, which can vary in quality and interpretation.
• Contextual Understanding: Ancient social and cultural contexts need careful consideration to avoid misinterpreting specific injunctions in a modern framework.
• Diverse Interpretations: The philosophical depth leads to various schools of thought (Darshanas) and commentaries, requiring discernment.

Opportunities:

• Academic Study: Promoting rigorous academic study of these texts in universities globally to unearth their philosophical and historical depth.
• Accessible Translations and Commentaries: Encouraging the creation of high-quality, accessible translations and contemporary commentaries that bridge the ancient wisdom with modern understanding.
• Digital Preservation and Dissemination: Utilizing digital platforms, online courses, and multimedia to make these texts and their teachings widely available to a global audience.
• Interdisciplinary Dialogue: Fostering dialogue between Sanatan Dharma’s philosophical insights and modern science, psychology, ethics, and leadership studies.

---

6. Conclusion

The “Great Books” of Sanatan Dharma represent a living tradition of profound wisdom. From the cosmic hymns of the Vedas to the liberating philosophy of the Upanishads, the ethical narratives of the Itihasas, and the accessible stories of the Puranas, these texts offer a comprehensive guide to understanding existence, living a virtuous life, and realizing ultimate truth. In an era marked by rapid change, fragmentation, and a search for meaning, the timeless principles embedded in these scriptures provide a robust framework for individual fulfillment and collective harmony, cementing their status as an indispensable source of universal wisdom for all humanity.

---

Industrial Application of Sanatan Dharma Great Books?

While Sanatan Dharma’s “Great Books” are primarily spiritual and philosophical texts, their principles offer profound insights that can be applied to various aspects of modern industrial and corporate life. It’s not about directly using a Veda as a manufacturing manual, but rather extracting the timeless wisdom to foster ethical conduct, improve leadership, enhance organizational culture, and promote employee well-being.

Here are several “industrial applications” of Sanatan Dharma’s great books:

1. Ethical Leadership and Corporate Governance (Bhagavad Gita, Dharma Shastras, Itihasas)

• Nishkama Karma (Selfless Action) from the Bhagavad Gita:
  • Application: Encouraging employees and leaders to focus on the quality of their work and duties, rather than being solely driven by immediate personal gain or attachment to outcomes (e.g., bonuses, promotions). This fosters a sense of ownership, dedication, and reduces stress related to uncontrollable results.
  • Industrial Benefit: Leads to higher quality output, reduced burnout, ethical decision-making, and a more resilient workforce. Companies with this ethos might prioritize long-term sustainability over short-term profits.
• Dharma (Righteous Conduct/Duty):
  • Application: Defining and upholding a strong ethical code for the organization. This involves fairness in dealings with employees, customers, suppliers, and the environment. “Organizational Dharma” would mean aligning business practices with universal values (truth, honesty, non-harm).
  • Industrial Benefit: Builds trust, enhances brand reputation, attracts ethical investors and talent, and contributes to sustainable growth. It guides decision-making in complex situations, ensuring actions align with the greater good.
• Servant Leadership (Bhagavad Gita, Ramayana):
  • Application: Leaders acting as facilitators and guides, prioritizing the well-being and growth of their team members and stakeholders over personal power or prestige. Drawing from Rama’s ideal kingship or Krishna’s guidance to Arjuna.
  • Industrial Benefit: Boosts employee morale, fosters collaboration, increases innovation, and creates a more supportive and empowering work environment.
• Conflict Resolution and Emotional Intelligence (Mahabharata, Bhagavad Gita):
  • Application: The Mahabharata is a rich tapestry of conflict and human psychology. Lessons from Krishna’s diplomacy and the ethical dilemmas faced by characters can be used to develop negotiation skills, manage workplace conflicts, and cultivate emotional intelligence in leaders.
  • Industrial Benefit: Reduces internal friction, improves team cohesion, and enables more effective problem-solving.

2. Workplace Wellness and Productivity (Yoga Sutras of Patanjali)

• Ashtanga Yoga (Eight Limbs of Yoga):
  • Application:
    • Yamas (Ethical Restraints – e.g., Ahimsa, Satya): Promoting non-violence (no toxic work culture), truthfulness (transparency), non-stealing (integrity), and moderation in the workplace.
    • Niyamas (Self-Observances – e.g., Santosha, Tapas): Encouraging contentment (reducing perpetual dissatisfaction), self-discipline, and self-study (continuous learning and skill development).
    • Asana (Physical Postures): Corporate wellness programs incorporating desk yoga, stretching, and mindful movement to combat sedentary lifestyles and reduce physical strain.
    • Pranayama (Breath Control): Teaching breathing exercises to manage stress, improve focus, and enhance mental clarity before important meetings or during high-pressure tasks.
    • Pratyahara (Sense Withdrawal), Dharana (Concentration), Dhyana (Meditation): Implementing mindfulness and meditation breaks to improve focus, reduce distractions, and enhance cognitive function.
  • Industrial Benefit: Improved employee health (mental and physical), reduced stress-related absenteeism, increased productivity, enhanced creativity, better decision-making, and a more engaged workforce. Many companies already offer mindfulness and yoga programs based on these principles.

3. Innovation and Creativity (Upanishads, Vedic Principles)

• Non-duality (Advaita Vedanta from Upanishads):
  • Application: Fostering a mindset of interconnectedness within the organization and with its ecosystem. Breaking down silos, encouraging cross-functional collaboration, and seeing complex problems as integrated systems rather than isolated issues. This can lead to more holistic solutions and innovative approaches.
  • Industrial Benefit: Enhanced synergy, more robust problem-solving, and the development of integrated products/services.
• Self-Inquiry and Introspection:
  • Application: Encouraging a culture of continuous learning, self-reflection, and critical thinking at all levels. The Upanishadic quest for “knowing the Self” can be metaphorically applied to an organization’s quest for understanding its core purpose, strengths, and weaknesses.
  • Industrial Benefit: Drives continuous improvement, adaptive strategies, and fosters a learning organization.

4. Human Resource Management and Talent Development (Dharma Shastras, Puranas)

• Varna-Dharma (Duty based on inherent nature/aptitude – often misinterpreted as caste system):
  • Application (modern, non-caste context): Recognizing and nurturing individual talents, aptitudes, and strengths within the workforce. Placing individuals in roles where their inherent nature and skills (svabhava) align with their responsibilities, leading to greater job satisfaction and performance.
  • Industrial Benefit: Optimal talent utilization, higher employee engagement, reduced attrition, and a more productive workforce.
• “Work as Worship” (Karma Yoga):
  • Application: Instilling a sense of sacredness and dedication towards one’s work, seeing it not merely as a means to an end (salary) but as an opportunity for personal growth and contribution to the larger whole.
  • Industrial Benefit: Increased work commitment, higher quality of work, and a sense of purpose that transcends financial incentives.

Examples of Companies/Leaders Applying These Principles:

While specific companies rarely announce they are “applying the Rig Veda,” many leaders and organizations, particularly in India, consciously or unconsciously integrate these principles. For instance:

• “Indian Ethos in Management” is a recognized field that draws heavily from Sanatan Dharma’s texts.
• Many CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) initiatives align with the concept of Dharma and selfless service.
• The emphasis on holistic employee development and stress reduction programs in modern corporations often mirrors principles found in the Yoga Sutras and elements of the Bhagavad Gita.

In conclusion, the “industrial application” of Sanatan Dharma’s Great Books lies in leveraging their profound wisdom to create more ethical, harmonious, productive, and ultimately successful organizations that prioritize both profit and purpose, human well-being, and societal contribution.

References

1. ^ Jump up to:^a b c d “Sanatana dharma | Hinduism”. Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 4 July 2021.
2. ^ Jump up to:^a b Lester R. Kurtz (2007), Gods in the global village: the world’s religions in sociological perspective, Pine Forge Press, 2007, p. 49, ISBN 978-1-4129-2715-4, … Hinduism — or Sanatana Dharma, as some believers prefer to call it — is askewed now in religious tradition and the remenants of the Truth of it is what is being talked about here. It now encompass layers of complex deposits from many different cultures over the centuries. Its remarkable diversity and doctrinal tolerance …
3. ^ Rajarajan, R. K. K. (January 2020). Drāviḍian/Tamil Concept of Religion is sanātanadharma a Religion?. Into the Nuances of Culture. Essays on Culture Studies.
4. ^ “The concept of Sanatan Dharma: its roots and the historical context of its use”. The Indian Express. 4 September 2023. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
5. ^ Jump up to:^a b so Harvey, Andrew (2001). Teachings of the Hindu Mystics. Boulder: Shambhala. pp. xiii. ISBN 1-57062-449-6.). See also René Guénon, Introduction to the Study of the Hindu Doctrines (1921 ed.), Sophia Perennis, ISBN 0-900588-74-8, part III, chapter 5 “The Law of Manu”, p. 146. On the meaning of the word “Dharma”, see also René Guénon, Studies in Hinduism, Sophia Perennis, ISBN 0-900588-69-3, chapter 5, p. 45
6. ^ Jump up to:^a b “Sanatana Dharma”. The Heart of Hinduism. Retrieved 17 April 2020. Dharma is often translated as “duty,” “religion” or “religious duty” and yet its meaning is more profound, defying concise English translation. The word itself comes from the Sanskrit root “dhri,” which means “to sustain.” Another related meaning is “that which is integral to something.” For example, the dharma of sugar is to be sweet and the dharma of fire to be hot. Therefore, a person’s dharma consists of duties that sustain them, according to their innate characteristics. Such characteristics are both material and spiritual, generating two corresponding types of dharma:
   
   (a) Sanatana-dharma – duties which take into account the person’s spiritual (constitutional) identity as atman and are thus the same for everyone.
   
   (b) Varnashrama-dharma – duties performed according to one’s material (conditional) nature and specific to the individual at that particular time (see Varnashrama Dharma).
   
   According to the notion of sanatana-dharma, the eternal and intrinsic inclination of the living entity (atman) is to perform seva (service). Sanatana-dharma, being transcendental, refers to universal and axiomatic laws that are beyond our temporary belief systems. …
7. ^ Manusmriti (4-138), … “Satyam bruyatpriyam bruyanna bruyatsatyamapriyam. Priyam cha nanrtam bruyadesa dharmah sanatanah.” (Translation: “Speak the truth, speak the truth that is pleasant. Do not speak the truth to manipulate. Do not speak falsely to please or flatter someone. This is the quality of the eternal dharma“) …
8. ^ Swami Prabhupada, Bhaktivedanda, “Srimad-Bhagavatam (Bhagavata Purana) (8.14.4)”, Bhaktivedanda Vedabase, … “catur-yugānte kālena grastāñ chruti-gaṇān yathā । tapasā ṛṣayo ‘paśyan yato dharmaḥ sanātanaḥ” (Translation: “At the end of every four yugas, the great saintly persons, upon seeing that the eternal [sanātanaḥ] occupational duties [dharmaḥ] of mankind have been misused, reestablish the principles of religion.”) …. Other shlokas are 3.16.18 (sanātano dharmo); 7.11.2 (dharmaṁ sanātanam); 7.11.5 (sanātanaṁ dharmaṁ); 8.8.39, 8.14.4, 10.4.39 (dharmaḥ sanātanaḥ).
9. ^ Authority, Anxiety, and Canon By Laurie L. Patton, P. 103.
10. ^ The Concise Oxford Dictionary of World Religions. Ed. John Bowker. Oxford University Press, 2000
11. ^ J. Zavos, Defending Hindu Tradition: Sanatana Dharma as a Symbol of Orthodoxy in Colonial India, Religion (Academic Press), Volume 31, Number 2, April 2001, pp. 109-123; see also R. D. Baird, “Swami Bhaktivedanta and the Encounter with Religions”, Modern Indian Responses to Religious Pluralism, edited by Harold Coward, State University of New York Press, 1987)
12. ^ Dansk etnografisk forening (1995), Folk, Volumes 36-37, Dansk etnografisk forening, 1995, … The Arya Samaj and their activities can be understood as representing a cultural revivalist movement … the orthodox Hindus, the Sanatanis, who supported and protected Sanatana Dharm (eternal religion) …
13. ^ Anupama Arya (2001), Religion and politics in India: a study of the role of Arya Samaj, K.K. Publications, 2001, … the Samaj is opposed to idol worship which is practised in the traditional Sanatana Dharma of Hindu … difference between the Arya Samaj and those movements was that the former was a revivalist and a fundamentalist movement …
14. ^ Robin Rinehart (1999), One lifetime, many lives: the experience of modern Hindu hagiography, Oxford University Press US, 1999, p. 20, ISBN 978-0-7885-0555-3, … the Lahore Sanatana Dharma Sabha [society for the eternal dharma], which was an organization dedicated to preserving what it considered the true Hindu tradition against the onslaught of reform and revival groups …
15. ^ “Sanatana Mission”. Sanatana Mission. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
16. ^ Thillayvel Naidoo (1992), The Arya Samaj movement in South Africa, Motilal Banarsidass Publ., 1992, ISBN 978-81-208-0769-3, … The reception accorded the Arya Samaj … The Hindu community … was split into two camps, one supportive and the other antagonistic … attitudes of intransigence which characterised dialogue between the two groups … the two terms “Samajists” and “Sanatanis” came into vogue …
17. ^ Philip Lutgendorf (1991), The life of a text: performing the Rāmcaritmānas of Tulsidas, University of California Press, 1991, ISBN 978-0-520-06690-8, … Perhaps the most significant impact of the Arya Samaj, the most reformist … came from the organizational model it presented, which increasingly came to be emulated by orthodox groups … the Sanatan Dharm Rakshini Sabha … formed in Calcutta in 1873 …
18. ^ Tika Ram Sharma, D. M. Gupta (1987), Essays on Rabindranath Tagore, Vimal Prakashan, 1987, … The aftermath of the bitter and violent attack of Aryasamaj on idol-worship and an equally enthusiastic rebuttal by Sanatanis in the first three decades of this century presented as alarming a scene as a clash between Hindu and Muslim …
19. ^ Agehananda Bharati (Swami) (1972), The Asians in East Africa: Jayhind and UhuruProfessional-technical series, Nelson-Hall Co., 1972, ISBN 978-0-911012-49-1, … If we regard the Arya Samaj as a Protestant movement— and it is that on all counts— and the sanatanis as the traditionalists, the Hindu “Catholics,” so to speak …
20. Kane, P.V. History of the Dharmaśāstras Vol. 1 p. 304
21. ^ James Lochtefeld (2002), “Dharma Shastras” in The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Hinduism, Vol. 1: A-M, Rosen Publishing, ISBN 0-8239-2287-1, pages 191–192
22. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiii–xxv.
23. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, p. 73.
24. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 173, 175–176, 183.
25. ^ Patrick Olivelle, Manu’s Code of Law: A Critical Edition and Translation of the Mānava-Dharmaśāstra (New York: Oxford UP, 2005), 64.
26. ^ Ludo Rocher, “Hindu Law and Religion: Where to draw the line?” in Malik Ram Felicitation Volume, ed. S.A.J. Zaidi. (New Delhi, 1972), pp.167–194 and Richard W. Lariviere, “Law and Religion in India” in Law, Morality, and Religion: Global Perspectives, ed. Alan Watson (Berkeley: University of California Press), pp.75–94.
27. ^ Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu’s Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, pages 31–32, 81–82, 154–166, 208–214, 353–354, 356–382
28. ^ Donald Davis (2010), The Spirit of Hindu Law, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-0521877046, page 13-16, 166–179
29. ^ Kedar Nath Tiwari (1998). Classical Indian Ethical Thought. Motilal Banarsidass. pp. 88–95. ISBN 978-81-208-1607-7.
30. ^ Rocher, Ludo (July–September 1972). “Indian Response to Anglo-Hindu Law”. Journal of the American Oriental Society. 92 (3): 419–424. doi:10.2307/600567. JSTOR 600567.
31. ^ Jump up to:^a b Derrett, J. Duncan M. (November 1961). “The Administration of Hindu Law by the British”. Comparative Studies in Society and History. 4 (1). Cambridge University Press: 10–52. doi:10.1017/S0010417500001213. JSTOR 177940. S2CID 144344249.
32. ^ Jump up to:^a b Werner Menski (2003), Hindu Law: Beyond tradition and modernity, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-569921-0, Chapter 1
33. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxii.
34. ^ Jump up to:^{a b c d e} (Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiii)
35. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 7–8.
36. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 12.
37. ^ Rajendra Prasad (2009). A Historical-developmental Study of Classical Indian Philosophy of Morals. Concept. p. 147. ISBN 978-81-8069-595-7.
38. ^ Jump up to:^{a b c d e} Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiv–xxv.
39. ^ Jump up to:^a b (Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiii–xxv)
40. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 19–22, Quote: The dharma-sutra of Apastamba suggests that a rich literature on dharma already existed. He cites ten authors by name. (…).
41. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 178, see note 29 for a list of 17 cited ancient scholars in different Dharmasutras.
42. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 178.
43. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiv.
44. ^ Jump up to:^a b (Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxiv)
45. ^ Jump up to:^{a b c d e} (Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxv)
46. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Robert Lingat 1973, p. 18.
47. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 185.
48. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, p. 19.
49. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 19–20.
50. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 46.
51. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxvi.
52. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, p. 325.
53. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxi.
54. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 178 with note 28.
55. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxvii.
56. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxviii.
57. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxiv.
58. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxv.
59. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxvi.
60. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxvii.
61. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxviii–xxxix.
62. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxviii–xxxix, 27–28.
63. ^ Jump up to:^{a b c d e f} Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xxxix.
64. ^ Jump up to:^a b c d Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xl.
65. ^ Jump up to:^{a b c d e f g} Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xli.
66. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 180.
67. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 69.
68. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. 100–101.
69. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 181.
70. ^ Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. xlii.
71. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 1999, pp. x1ii.
72. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 73–77.
73. ^ Jump up to:^a b Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 169–170.
74. ^ Jump up to:^a b c d Timothy Lubin, Donald R. Davis Jr & Jayanth K. Krishnan 2010, p. 57.
75. ^ Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu’s Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, pages 24–25
76. ^ Flood 1996, p. 56.
77. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2005.
78. ^ Steven Collins (1993), The discourse of what is primary, Journal of Indian philosophy, Volume 21, pages 301–393
79. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2005, pp. 3–4.
80. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 77.
81. ^ Lingat 1973: 98
82. ^ Timothy Lubin, Donald R. Davis Jr & Jayanth K. Krishnan 2010, pp. 59–72.
83. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 98.
84. ^ Lariviere 1989.
85. ^ Olivelle 2007: 149–150.
86. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 277.
87. ^ Mandagadde Rama Jois 1984, pp. 22.
88. ^ Benoy Kumar Sarkar (1985). The Positive Background of Hindu Sociology. Motilal Banarsidass. pp. 192–194. ISBN 978-81-208-2664-9.
89. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 195–198.
90. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Robert Lingat 1973, p. 104.
91. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 188.
92. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 14, 109–110, 180–189.
93. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, p. 97.
94. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 98, 103–106.
95. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 130–131.
96. ^ Jump up to:^a b Robert Lingat 1973, p. 6.
97. ^ Jump up to:^a b c Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 173–174.
98. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 175–178, 184–185.
99. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 176–177.
100. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 22.
101. ^ Patrick Olivelle (2005), Manu’s Code of Law, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0195171464, pages 353–354, 356–382
102. ^ G Srikantan (2014), Entanglements in Legal History (Editor: Thomas Duve), Max Planck Institute: Germany, ISBN 978-3944773001, page 123
103. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 129–131.
104. ^ P.V. Kane, History of Dharmaśāstra: (ancient and mediaeval, religious and civil law). (Poona: Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, 1962 – 1975).
105. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 158–159.
106. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 103, 159.
107. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, p. 172.
108. ^ Patrick Olivelle 2006, pp. 172–173.
109. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, pp. 14–16.
110. ^ Robert Lingat 1973, p. 285.